(;GM[1]FF[4]CA[UTF-8]AP[CGoban:3]ST[2] RU[Japanese]SZ[19]KM[6.50]TM[3600]OT[5x40 byo-yomi] PW[CrazyStone]PB[fj]BR[6d]DT[2014-10-11]PC[The KGS Go Server at http://www.gokgs.com/]C[CrazyStone [-\]: GTP Engine for CrazyStone (white): Crazy Stone version http://remi.coulom.free.fr/CrazyStone/ firstkyu [5d\]: go FJ! fj [6d\]: ok, have fun GoRoGoRo [?\]: go fj ]RE[B+Resign] ;B[pe]BL[3579.62]C[fj [6d\]: Remi and the spectators ;-) GoRoGoRo [?\]: Wer ohne Fehler spielt, setze den zweiten Stein! ] ;W[pp]WL[3561.672]C[keiler [?\]: Mein Jott, seit ihr pünktlich! First [3k?\]: fj could become european professional go player GoKlaus [1k?\]: jupp, kannst du die Uhr danach stellen qpax [1d\]: roln could give b two stones ] ;B[co]BL[3490.25]C[First [3k?\]: no gogonuts [5d\]: gogo FJ!!! First [3k?\]: fj is strong firstkyu [5d\]: Yay! kmlck [2d\]: fj strong in slow games firstkyu [5d\]: I think this is a good choice GoIngo [?\]: normal geht anders ;-) ] ;W[dd]WL[3523.101]C[Muttley [2k\]: Hi Remi, and thanks for participating in this challenge GoRoGoRo [?\]: CrazyStone is wartching, too! Muttley [2k\]: very interesting firstkyu [5d\]: komplicate joseki + no moyo ] ;B[qn]BL[3469.457]C[GoIngo [?\]: there will be an ellipsoid from lower left to upper right gogonuts [5d\]: i dont think diagonal fuseki is good against bots firstkyu [5d\]: btw. how manny moves has the CS Joseki Database? ] ;W[dq]WL[3484.695]C[gogonuts [5d\]: lots of small fights make it hard gogonuts [5d\]: none, i think gogonuts [5d\]: no 19*19 book gogonuts [5d\]: but ofcourse lots of joseki and pattern knowledge RemiCoulom [3k?\]: It is not really a joseki database. But patterns. It is a bit similar. keiler [?\]: E4 now ] ;B[ep]BL[3409.975]C[keiler [?\]: oh RemiCoulom [3k?\]: about 3-4 million patterns. gogonuts [5d\]: wow First [3k?\]: I don't get it firstkyu [5d\]: thanks ] ;W[eq]WL[3465.423]C[gogonuts [5d\]: then fj has no chance :-) ] ;B[fp]BL[3406.525]C[First [3k?\]: fj underestimated bot last time First [3k?\]: and now he goes crazy fuseki again cjr [3d\]: how do you define a pattern? where do you obtain it from? firstkyu [5d\]: GinseiIgo blew this Joseki last time I used it gogonuts [5d\]: one drubbing wasnt enough for fj ] ;W[gq]WL[3432.708]C[gogonuts [5d\]: i understand his feelings RemiCoulom [3k?\]: They are automatically extracted from a collection of game records. firstkyu [5d\]: I used g4 GoIngo [?\]: the feelings? cjr [3d\]: :-) GoIngo [?\]: ;-) firstkyu [5d\]: do you use KGS games too? firstkyu [5d\]: like 8d - 9d KGS? firstkyu [5d\]: or just Pro games afar [3d?\]: Who won game 1? gogonuts [5d\]: that we will not change a lifetime of habits of what he thinks is right because of a single loss RemiCoulom [3k?\]: A pattern is a configuration of stones around a move. I used 4d+ KGS games. So, maybe some of yours ;-) ] ;B[ci]BL[3344.407]C[maproomad [-\]: CS won game 1 Uniqo [1d\]: so that is machine learning afar [3d?\]: Thanks maproomad gogonuts [5d\]: and very convincingly cjr [3d\]: Have you tried if it gets stronger or weaker if you remove firstkyu's games from the database? Muttley [2k\]: hmm, 4d+, no joseki from my games. Sad. ] ;W[pc]WL[3394.114]C[firstkyu [5d\]: lol, if you use my games, FJ will win Lumpenhund [5d\]: +1 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Yes. If you want all the details: http://remi.coulom.free.fr/Amsterdam2007/ gogonuts [5d\]: too bad muttley, your patterns might have made cs stumble :-) ] ;B[nd]BL[3324.29]C[firstkyu [5d\]: I still blunder in Joseki Hofobbefes [3d\]: I need one more dan, and CS will start opening with l17! Muttley [2k\]: ironically, fj could be playing against his own joseki choices then firstkyu [5d\]: thanks a lot Remi Muttley [2k\]: yeah, CS would have benefited from Muttsuji for sure ] ;W[qe]WL[3355.36]C[firstkyu [5d\]: you are realy putting up a great show for us GoIngo [?\]: cs gets all four corners today? firstkyu [5d\]: r16 now? firstkyu [5d\]: to get a fight started? Muttley [2k\]: the thing is, there's probably 12+ choices at each move, so I guess they are candidates and analysed as such gogonuts [5d\]: fj doesnt feel like getting hunted in a moyo today firstkyu [5d\]: r16 is a complicated Joseki with some modern changes lately gogonuts [5d\]: very enticing to see how cs handles r16 :-) firstkyu [5d\]: ladders work for black Muttley [2k\]: Kasparov, when he started playing bots in matches, said the psychology is very different- they don't get tired or subjective if they make a mistake or get "under pressure" firstkyu [5d\]: + r6 well placed rs220675 [1d\]: white has all four corners firstkyu [5d\]: b might go for it cjr [3d\]: Remi - may I ask you, the "Engine game" feature included in Champion Go, it is much weaker than this version of CrazyStone? (sorry it's a little off topic, but curious) rs220675 [1d\]: black plays with a lot of respect for cs Muttley [2k\]: thank you rs220675, hoshi are corners, that's exactly what I say rsun [5d\]: does b use this fuseki against humans as well? rsun [5d\]: b thinking of r16?? gogonuts [5d\]: must be rsun [5d\]: usually hamete doesn't work gogonuts [5d\]: its not hamete gogonuts [5d\]: and ladders are good gogonuts [5d\]: it would be areasonable choice RemiCoulom [3k?\]: champion go is the same software, but hardware matters too. Muttley [2k\]: I thought r16 was a standard sac sequence to seal w in kmlck [2d\]: hamate=inside hane? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: on a tablet or cell phone, there little cpu power available. gogonuts [5d\]: but fj might actually decide to avoid hand to hand combat Muttley [2k\]: no, unreasonable move Muttley [2k\]: trying to get more than the position allows kmlck [2d\]: you mean my every move Muttley [2k\]: and that Laman [2d\]: hamete = high level joseki trick First [3k?\]: is this bot stronger than zen? firstkyu [5d\]: I think players like Gogo and me should choose r16 here rsun [5d\]: hamete is the brother of hamlet Krapsman [1d\]: r14 seems more logical with global board Amenophis [6k?\]: hamtete is a trick play, hoping the foe will fall in a trap qpax [1d\]: it's not gogonuts [5d\]: in 3 years your 8 core cell phone will kick your butt :-) firstkyu [5d\]: cause we are too weak to win without a lokal plus in the beginning Muttley [2k\]: its not really a trick play ] ;B[qf]BL[3043.039]C[qpax [1d\]: zen is slightly better, at least in kgs tournamets pope: in 3 years you'll be happy if landlines work Muttley [2k\]: but I don't want to argue semantics here :) ] ;W[qd]WL[3333.982]C[gogonuts [5d\]: maximum restraint ] ;B[rf]BL[3038.733]C[firstkyu [5d\]: in chess cell phones are so strong, top players cant handle them firstkyu [5d\]: oh supervirus [4k\]: bot will be unbeatable in a few years. meat computers will have to get another hobby gogonuts [5d\]: alomost maximum restraint :-) firstkyu [5d\]: thats a trange choice again rsun [5d\]: why fj plays so thinly Mneme [2k\]: Rémi How many cores ? ] ;W[nb]WL[3295.671]C[RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 54% win rate now. ] ;B[mf]BL[3031.489]C[Amenophis [6k?\]: what? where? Hofobbefes [3d\]: never seen this shape firstkyu [5d\]: I think this way of taking gote is worse than just Q14 + take sente pope: just delete o16 gogonuts [5d\]: 54 is already quite high, but all bots bias in their own direction rsun [5d\]: q9 kmlck [2d\]: using unconvential shapes is good tact against bots pope: and it's normal ] ;W[np]WL[3257.266]C[KlausB [?\]: Remi: I take it that win rates are given for CS? cjr [3d\]: this is in 38 basic joseki... fj showing that he learnt go a long time ago :) Lumpenhund [5d\]: b wants n18 gogonuts [5d\]: at 50% there own position is almost surely worse Krapsman [1d\]: doesn't seem very thick RemiCoulom [3k?\]: KlausB: yes. 55% now. rs220675 [1d\]: fj wants cs to invade^^ ] ;B[pk]BL[3005.726]C[Hofobbefes [3d\]: looks like an Hokuto shape joseki RemiCoulom [3k?\]: And it is right that it tends to be optimistic. cjr [3d\]: does it decide time use based on the volatility of the position? First [3k?\]: but does this bot require a lot of cores? globax [3d\]: d10? ] ;W[gp]WL[3218.849]C[firstkyu [5d\]: well when I think my position is 30%, then I am usually just lost... gogonuts [5d\]: lol GoIngo [?\]: CS runs fine on my 2-core machine First [3k?\]: dual core ] ;B[mb]BL[2948.215]C[RemiCoulom [3k?\]: In this game the algorithm for time use is 38 second per move. If the move is forced, it may take 19 second, but never less. CBlue [2d?\]: wish someone would translate the korean Go comics on hangame.co.kr Zenmid [6k\]: In this match CS uses 5930K(6core) right? ] ;W[cg]WL[3179.839]C[pipong [2d\]: n14 feel good now GoIngo [?\]: CBlue: is that comic on computers? gogonuts [5d\]: nice cs tenuki jinroo [3d?\]: not really RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Zenmid: right. jinroo [3d?\]: p18 hugwe jinroo [3d?\]: huge ] ;B[ei]BL[2904.785]C[rs220675 [1d\]: n18 seems too slow jinroo [3d?\]: I dont think so jinroo [3d?\]: after p18 now by b cjr [3d\]: P18 follow-up is huge, normally it is sente gogonuts [5d\]: n18 isnt slow - was hoping to test w response jinroo [3d?\]: and should be sente ] ;W[ck]WL[3141.423]C[CBlue [2d?\]: GoIngo, it's like http://images.hangame.co.kr/upload/baduk/2010/column/cartoon_baduk_97.jpg cjr [3d\]: wow Lumpenhund [5d\]: wow cjr [3d\]: i was first Lumpenhund [5d\]: :-) gogonuts [5d\]: b e9 androgo [1d\]: C10 now rs220675 [1d\]: crazy from crazystone^^ gogonuts [5d\]: pretty hard work for w RemiCoulom [3k?\]: E9 E7 D8 D7 expected. cjr [3d\]: E7 is unique thinking Leonidas [2k\]: Remi, what data structure you use to represent board and stones? reprisal [3d\]: thats not very reasonable to expect :9 gogonuts [5d\]: androgo - e9 is the way to take away connection here GoIngo [?\]: remi, how long are principal lines in average? CBlue [2d?\]: i cant find the direct link to the comics overview atm :/ CBlue [2d?\]: all in korean -_- jinroo [3d?\]: e9 e7 c7 looks good for b androgo [1d\]: Hm, elegant jinroo [3d?\]: to me RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Data structure is top secret ;-) GoIngo [?\]: ;-) DasWiesel [9k\]: 6d bot? Leonidas [2k\]: I see :) blackh [10k\]: Remi, what programming language? kmlck [2d\]: so did zen surpass crazystone? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: C++ rsun [5d\]: come on, fj, you are germany's hope firstkyu [5d\]: e9 now gogonuts [5d\]: it really needs to be e9 next, imo GoIngo [?\]: german's next top model ?! firstkyu [5d\]: is w alive after p18? Leonidas [2k\]: fj is mankind's hope cjr [3d\]: D8 or F9? gogonuts [5d\]: p18 cant kill cjr [3d\]: some interesting possibilities nearby if he wants to be inventive :) firstkyu [5d\]: I think p18 is sente rs220675 [1d\]: the danger of c9 is his potential to split black locally there firstkyu [5d\]: thats what I mean ] ;B[cq]BL[2702.11]C[gogonuts [5d\]: i think thats right First [3k?\]: c9 is the right spot rsun [5d\]: d8 gin will tenuki for sure... gogonuts [5d\]: but fj has had his hands full gogonuts [5d\]: uh oh gogonuts [5d\]: fancy time ] ;W[dp]WL[3103.018]C[gogonuts [5d\]: w fine with e9, imo GoIngo [?\]: bye bye moyo rsun [5d\]: gogo have you played fj in person? gogonuts [5d\]: y firstkyu [5d\]: of course gogonuts [5d\]: at german championships firstkyu [5d\]: more than once rsun [5d\]: does he use this opening? gogonuts [5d\]: always lost against him firstkyu [5d\]: he changes his opening all the time Lumpenhund [5d\]: he likes 54 rsun [5d\]: ic firstkyu [5d\]: but its like here firstkyu [5d\]: a little bit strange an overstreched for my point of view ] ;B[cp]BL[2629.972]C[firstkyu [5d\]: wow rsun [5d\]: my eyes are popping gogonuts [5d\]: creative fj androgo [1d\]: Unexpected Krapsman [1d\]: f6 ? cjr [3d\]: this is not the biggest move, nor is it the strongest... he is testing me ] ;W[do]WL[3073.448]C[rsun [5d\]: gogo, if I play that in my game, I'm sure you won't use the word "creative" ;) Lumpenhund [5d\]: nice idea firstkyu [5d\]: ok for b I think ] ;B[dn]BL[2624.344]C[RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 56.6% Muttley [2k\]: who for, CS? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: E9 next Vogel [?\]: what does 56.6 mean? Leonidas [2k\]: skynet has detected a weakness in the human RemiCoulom [3k?\]: yes, for CS. Muttley [2k\]: winrate Muttley [2k\]: thanks gogonuts [5d\]: my best successes against bots are blindingly boring games - the fancy positions i tend to lose rsun [5d\]: means it will win ] ;W[ek]WL[3034.473]C[Muttley [2k\]: my best wins are just plodding on and not playing atari, seems to fool them rsun [5d\]: I don't see how the creativity is working here Lumpenhund [5d\]: wait gogonuts [5d\]: i still think fj should have gone with e9 ] ;B[gi]BL[2571.699]C[androgo [1d\]: Whats blacks Plan? Leonidas [2k\]: gogonuts, bots have superior reading ability, so keeping positions simple and "boring" is good :) First [3k?\]: right gogonuts [5d\]: that would have given him thickness plus p18 sente plus the next move firstkyu [5d\]: jup firstkyu [5d\]: e9 was normal First [3k?\]: gogonuts would know First [3k?\]: he plays them 100 times a day' rsun [5d\]: it seems b want to run into the center to prevent w moyo ] ;W[gk]WL[2996.097]C[rsun [5d\]: maybe b aiming at f16 or sth gogonuts [5d\]: cash in at p18, then come in at m3? CBlue [2d?\]: d18? rsun [5d\]: d18 seems inconsistent CBlue [2d?\]: c17? ^^ rsun [5d\]: b is playing very high jinroo [3d?\]: f17 nice point i think firstkyu [5d\]: time for p18? ] ;B[ij]BL[2489.37]C[gogonuts [5d\]: btw, kudos to cs for c9 - other bots would be afraid to play that way globax [3d\]: e17 rsun [5d\]: c9 is a pro move gogonuts [5d\]: bullies are often weak at defense themselves :-) rsun [5d\]: invade right after you defend ] ;W[fh]WL[2957.756]C[rsun [5d\]: it creates strong psychological effect RemiCoulom [3k?\]: F12 F11 D12 D11 E6 ] ;B[fi]BL[2481.343]C[gogonuts [5d\]: well, i dont think cs has psychological patterns :-) ] ;W[dh]WL[2919.399] ;B[di]BL[2472.521]C[gogonuts [5d\]: bub defending often creates the situation that now is the last chance to invade gogonuts [5d\]: before, it wasnt urgent globax [3d\]: w lost b11 here firstkyu [5d\]: i hate i cant stay ] ;W[en]WL[2880.54]C[firstkyu [5d\]: sooooo nervous globax [3d\]: so e6 mandatory First [3k?\]: where you going? Hendl [1d\]: center is blacks nice obening for the kohlenstoff rsun [5d\]: b needs to make his gomoku work ] ;B[dm]BL[2442.688]C[firstkyu [5d\]: playing with kids firstkyu [5d\]: :) firstkyu [5d\]: cu all First [3k?\]: cool First [3k?\]: bye' GoIngo [?\]: yu GoIngo [?\]: cu ] ;W[em]WL[2860.567]C[RobotZombi [1k\]: computers are strong enough to play even against a 6d these days? o_0 Mneme [2k\]: yes Muttley [2k\]: like it or not, CS says "Ima havin a moyo" qpax [1d\]: since 2011 gogonuts [5d\]: still p18, then m3 globax [3d\]: g17? DasWiesel [9k\]: according to the website, crazystone won a HC 4 game against a 9p Mneme [2k\]: bot win last game Leonidas [2k\]: yes, german champ is like paper to them.. not strong at all Hendl [1d\]: i bet human will win today Mneme [2k\]: i would not bet on any of them BOThater36 [4d\]: Are they playing Jubango? what is the record so far? gogonuts [5d\]: so bet against one :-) gogonuts [5d\]: its best of 5 BOThater36 [4d\]: see Hendl [1d\]: this opening is so good for black gogonuts [5d\]: cs 1 fj 0 cjr [3d\]: not clearly good for b RemiCoulom [3k?\]: J8 expected. First [3k?\]: rather First [3k?\]: b has a long stick dragon Leonidas [2k\]: where would lee sedol play? cjr [3d\]: P18 in sente first, and then approach upper left? First [3k?\]: is now the time for f17? gogonuts [5d\]: not clearly good is actually bad, because if the bot just gets through the opening with an even position, it survived its weakest phase Hendl [1d\]: b has the center and white many holes First [3k?\]: I agree First [3k?\]: bot has better position at this stage Hofobbefes [3d\]: b has not the center Muttley [2k\]: Hello gghideki :) rsun [5d\]: m5 playable gogonuts [5d\]: m5 too soft First [3k?\]: ah the famous gghideki rsun [5d\]: if cs m3, then r3 ] ;B[jl]BL[2181.658]C[pollux1: is p18 sente all the way for b? First [3k?\]: of the legendary zenbots GoIngo [?\]: right Hofobbefes [3d\]: ok now he got a bit of center :-) rs220675 [1d\]: so it will be a moyo vs. moyo^^ OneEyed [?\]: After Go, Pictionary will be humanity's last stand ;) ] ;W[qo]WL[2822.167]C[rs220675 [1d\]: who can better reduce the others moyo while building his own ] ;B[pn]BL[2154.82]C[gogonuts [5d\]: i think k8 is too laid back Hofobbefes [3d\]: that is a good flow to beat bots imo GoIngo [?\]: when it looks like "pudding" cs will act fine cjr [3d\]: what looks like pudding, the black moyo? Laman [2d\]: Arimaa gonna fall before go? ] ;W[gg]WL[2783.156]C[gogonuts [5d\]: maybe s6 for s7 before closing the bottom? gogonuts [5d\]: oh cjr [3d\]: Arimaa may fall because so few humans play it Hendl [1d\]: funy move Lumpenhund [5d\]: hm g13 Uniqo [1d\]: who plays arimaa anyway GoIngo [?\]: "when" the center looks like ... gogonuts [5d\]: is that a note of ill intent? :-) Laman [2d\]: no one. and no one programs the bots :) rsun [5d\]: g13 is "before jumping you need to bend your knees" ] ;B[ob]BL[2099.186]C[gogonuts [5d\]: high time for p18 gogonuts [5d\]: had to play it before the area gets busy RemiCoulom [3k?\]: CS wants to tenuki. Hofobbefes [3d\]: what about c17 for b? ] ;W[ig]WL[2744.707]C[BreizhI [1k\]: nice it should rsun [5d\]: b shape at j10 area is very worrisome Hendl [1d\]: red ear move cjr [3d\]: :) could lead to new understanding of that upper right position gogonuts [5d\]: instead of k8 was a better time to get in p18 as sente Lumpenhund [5d\]: b can tenuki? rs220675 [1d\]: k12? cjr [3d\]: i dunno gogo, it cs doesn't think it is sente, it may never be sente... gogonuts [5d\]: right now cs has the right of sente rsun [5d\]: b has to fix h11 aji gogonuts [5d\]: i think cs thinks that j13 is bigger sente :-) rsun [5d\]: f8 probe RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 57.5% ] ;B[ji]BL[1990.756]C[FoH [-\]: is fj also bot? rs220675 [1d\]: for whom? DasWiesel [9k\]: remi winrate? rsun [5d\]: for cs, always gogonuts [5d\]: he just told us ] ;W[nc]WL[2725.337]C[Mneme [2k\]: fj humankind BOThater36 [4d\]: what is fj's resume? rs220675 [1d\]: ah ok, thx cjr [3d\]: does CS make any status computation for upper right? ] ;B[oc]BL[1982.26]C[rsun [5d\]: german champion Hendl [1d\]: fj is borg BOThater36 [4d\]: thx, rsun First [3k?\]: fj has won many tournaments Nilpferd [1k\]: 11 times german champion RobotZombi [1k\]: o17 wow ] ;W[mc]WL[2705.754]C[Zenmid [6k\]: Does CS use Ponder? ] ;B[pb]BL[1969.762]C[First [3k?\]: should have been 17 times german champion rsun [5d\]: it would be funny if CS > fj > gogo > CS First [3k?\]: but all is well Mneme [2k\]: yes zenmid Muttley [2k\]: Franz Josef Dickhut is leader of the resistance and man's last hope against the machines rs220675 [1d\]: I don't like black anymore gogonuts [5d\]: w o17 was the main reason b should have asked earlier rsun [5d\]: k16 sweet spot ] ;W[md]WL[2667.337]C[KlausB [?\]: rs22.. ddon't get personal .. :-) RemiCoulom [3k?\]: N16 59.5% Hendl [1d\]: resistance is promising Muttley [2k\]: why isn't this ok for b? rs220675 [1d\]: white has two potential moyos and black some pudding in the centre Muttley [2k\]: b traded a corner, that's ok surely First [3k?\]: b could definitely be a european professional Hendl [1d\]: w too:-) BOThater36 [4d\]: where is Calvin Sun? gogonuts [5d\]: because w never ansered in the corner and now gets great compensation on the outside Muttley [2k\]: Canada, Bot Jermelle [-\]: loll, I dont think calvin is here rsun [5d\]: AGA pros disappear shortly they become pro rsun [5d\]: after* IHateKos: I'm surprised IHateKos: Seeing how first is so civil BreizhI [1k\]: Remi Coulom, ce n'est pas un soucis d'avoir une grosse différence de niveau entre toi et CS ? je veux dire pour programmer cela ne change rien ? rsun [5d\]: je ne parle pas francais Horia [2k\]: l'élève a dépassé le maître on peut dire xD fluidistic [5k\]: hier fj a joué contre ginseiigo, un bot 5d. fj a perdu Jermelle [-\]: I agree with rsun, after they become pro, poof, gone Muttley [2k\]: Some of the best chessbots are programmed by rank amateurs, chesswise Muttley [2k\]: being strong doesn't mean you understand computer analysis BreizhI [1k\]: AH ok Muttley fluidistic [5k\]: being 5d in go is nothing. being 5d in programming is everything :D cjr [3d\]: Yeah, more important to be a good programmer :) gogonuts [5d\]: no choice about o15 imo Mneme [2k\]: non ca chane rien breizhl Rémi est un super fort proframmeur CBlue [2d?\]: why not n15? Muttley [2k\]: You're welcome, I understood Breizhl :) gogonuts [5d\]: and after w closes the top, b will have to live there BreizhI [1k\]: But sometimes it could be embarrassing right ? gogonuts [5d\]: or die :-) RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Breizhl: Non pas de souci. C'est très facile de comprendre les faiblesses du programme. First [3k?\]: does remi even speak french? First [3k?\]: oh fluidistic [5k\]: he's French chea7er [7d?\]: Really? chea7er [7d?\]: I thought Remi was Japanese rsun [5d\]: w j16 next? DasWiesel [9k\]: remi how many lines of code does CS have? Muttley [2k\]: onthe contrary, the weaker you are, the better it is that your bot is strong rsun [5d\]: how can coulom be japanese name fluidistic [5k\]: Remi is French and is professor in French university chea7er [7d?\]: But remi's profile is Japanese BreizhI [1k\]: Ah ok contre intuitif alors :p ] ;B[me]BL[1758.332]C[RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Long time did not count maybe 30k or 40k. depends how you count. Muttley [2k\]: Its so common in the chessworld that it is unremarkable chea7er [7d?\]: oh, this remi. I was thinking of a different remi RemiCoulom [3k?\]: I am not a professor any more. chea7er [7d?\]: sorry ] ;W[od]WL[2647.948]C[fluidistic [5k\]: oh I didn't know Rémi ] ;B[ne]BL[1747.284]C[fluidistic [5k\]: but still researcher? ] ;W[kd]WL[2628.072]C[rsun [5d\]: now n14 in bad position BOThater36 [4d\]: not a full time bot programmer? Muttley [2k\]: hmmm, still interesting RemiCoulom [3k?\]: I left to create my company. Horia [2k\]: winrate ? GoIngo [?\]: remi, lewt cs beat the best humans and you will hbecome professor again gogonuts [5d\]: terrible fluidistic [5k\]: ok Rémi :) ] ;B[hf]BL[1719.654]C[gogonuts [5d\]: r18 resurects the corner DasWiesel [9k\]: your company sells CS? cjr [3d\]: Are you hiring? ;) GoIngo [?\]: "unbalanced" sells cs rsun [5d\]: remi, please hire me as bot tester rsun [5d\]: I can play CS 8 hours a day ] ;W[hg]WL[2589.622]C[Horia [2k\]: ahah fluidistic [5k\]: I guess Rémi hires bots :) not humans wazi [3k\]: =)) gogonuts [5d\]: lol, rsun RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 62.5% now, btw. First [3k?\]: all the middle dan in here play bots 24/7 gogonuts [5d\]: this has gotten bad for fj rsun [5d\]: your CS will gain 2 stones after training intensively with me BreizhI [1k\]: it begin bigger and bigger BOThater36 [4d\]: to play bot, you have to use unconventional weapon DasWiesel [9k\]: D18 still possible? GoIngo [?\]: rsun, send me a mail please Jermelle [-\]: Where has gobugobu been? He'd make nice comments wazi [3k\]: hire me, i can code Java, C, HTML, Javascript..... ] ;B[dc]BL[1658.783]C[Leonidas [2k\]: both white corners still open for invasion cjr [3d\]: Do you create graphs to show the probability of ownership for each point in the final playout? GoIngo [?\]: ingo.althoefer@uni-jena.de cjr [3d\]: I think that would be really cool :) rsun [5d\]: mail you for..? Lilltiger [-\]: pr0n spam GoIngo [?\]: yes, and I explain everything ... ] ;W[ec]WL[2551.175]C[cjr [3d\]: life, the universe, and 42 ] ;B[eb]BL[1649.256]C[rsun [5d\]: what bot do you have? cjr [3d\]: you won't regret it gogonuts [5d\]: from here on, i think where ever fj tries to pick a fight cs will say ok, you can have some too gogonuts [5d\]: like in the first game BreizhI [1k\]: is e18 better than c17 ? ] ;W[ed]WL[2512.902]C[Lumpenhund [5d\]: e16 rocksolid GoIngo [?\]: I have no bot, but a group at Univesity RemiCoulom [3k?\]: CS hesitated between both. rsun [5d\]: how can I help you? GoIngo [?\]: mail me, and I will explain rsun [5d\]: o.o ] ;B[db]BL[1581.248]C[pope: sounds legit rs220675 [1d\]: like in the first game cs is destroying fj methodically ] ;W[fb]WL[2474.419] ;B[cd]BL[1567.866]C[cjr [3d\]: b16? cjr [3d\]: probably not globax [3d\]: b16? kmlck [2d\]: f17 aji my prevent b16 kmlck [2d\]: may* gogonuts [5d\]: its very hard to get off the road to perdition against a bot, once your on it rsun [5d\]: is the job description "play bot 8 hours a day"? BreizhI [1k\]: Rémi, this is test game for CS ? Or something else ? ] ;W[ce]WL[2435.544]C[GoIngo [?\]: it is better fluidistic [5k\]: Rémi, could you let cs play on kgs after this game? Some of us are in heaven when cs is here GoRoGoRo [?\]: 10 hours? ] ;B[bd]BL[1551.515]C[rsun [5d\]: lol GoIngo [?\]: ;-) wampleek [?\]: Cs is a not? BreizhI [1k\]: Yeah it will be very nice :) RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Breizhl: this is the codecentric challenge. wampleek [?\]: Not* rsun [5d\]: but frankly I don't know much programming BreizhI [1k\]: AH ok merci, ] ;W[hi]WL[2396.164]C[Muttley [2k\]: Lots of questions for Remi, do respect his privacy re: programming though :) GoIngo [?\]: my horizon is wide - and all my students are differentz Muttley [2k\]: you're all good :) RemiCoulom [3k?\]: fluidistic: sorry, I have only one machine and use it for testing CS. RemiCoulom [3k?\]: But I may connect a slower one to calibrate the weak levels. pope: What's CS pope: oh ] ;B[hj]BL[1525.638]C[pope: ic cjr [3d\]: does h11 do anything? RobotZombi [1k\]: cs = computer science Muttley [2k\]: what is interesting about the bot is it does very little about b's moyo gogonuts [5d\]: b getting bamboozzled? rsun [5d\]: oh this is phd opening? Muttley [2k\]: it let's b play where it builds strength, very subtle ] ;W[kh]WL[2356.882]C[gogonuts [5d\]: this is starting to look like a cat toying with a mouse fluidistic [5k\]: ok thx Remi gogonuts [5d\]: poor fj Hendl [1d\]: k12 rsun [5d\]: gogo, you should play the rest of the match for fj :) Uniqo [1d\]: b18 is ko dyago [5k\]: whos cat fluidistic [5k\]: there is ginseiigo (5d) bot on kgs currently Rémi. if you want to test cs vs it ... :) feel free to go ahead fluidistic [5k\]: zen played it a few times ] ;B[jh]BL[1432.038] ;W[jg]WL[2318.402]C[First [3k?\]: it's too latae First [3k?\]: the bot is aiming for half point win Zenmid [6k\]: CS is in even good situation...? about 20 GoIngo [?\]: rsun, simply mail me ... ] ;B[ke]BL[1362.783]C[qpax [1d\]: it's not bots aiming for 0.5 win, it's humans aiming for 0.5 loss GoIngo [?\]: rsun, simply mail me GoRoGoRo [?\]: (please) rsun [5d\]: I can assume the job is PhD studentship? GoIngo [?\]: rsun, simply mail me rsun [5d\]: ... Muttley [2k\]: guys, take it private :) First [3k?\]: please rsun [5d\]: how about PM here ] ;W[je]WL[2279.957]C[GoRoGoRo [?\]: yeah, and then tell us Muttley [2k\]: thanks rsun nhanh [3d\]: cut First [3k?\]: do it via mail kmlck [2d\]: cut works? kmlck [2d\]: cs is tricked? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: K16 L17 G18 F17 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: expected. RobotZombi [1k\]: I expect L13 kmlck [2d\]: me2 ] ;B[kg]BL[1274.818]C[awesome [3k\]: fj kicking back Horia [2k\]: but now, white sente kmlck [2d\]: this looks good for b fluidistic [5k\]: K16 was expected TheNewONe [-\]: this look really bad for b... Horia [2k\]: cs will perhaps invade ] ;W[kf]WL[2241.637]C[fluidistic [5k\]: I am sure cs has the refutation of L13 ] ;B[lg]BL[1269.529]C[globax [3d\]: n7 fluidistic [5k\]: N8 dyago [5k\]: o9 qpax [1d\]: atari and tenuki seems decent refutation rs220675 [1d\]: I also think the time setting could be improved next time for a human vs. bot match: at least 2h thinking time plus byo. fluidistic [5k\]: or M8 pollux1: n8 dangerous n7 better ] ;W[mo]WL[2202.858]C[Muttley [2k\]: lol fluidistic [5k\]: lol N5 gogonuts [5d\]: awesome dyago [5k\]: bots like space before fights TheNewONe [-\]: n5 say it is enought for me rsun [5d\]: p3 probe rsun [5d\]: now or never First [3k?\]: b humiliated GoIngo [?\]: remi, % please pollux1: life possible in corner with r18 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 66% GoIngo [?\]: thx globax [3d\]: o2 all out ? Muttley [2k\]: it is remarkable how it plays unprejudiced moves Ootakamoku [4d?\]: p3 probe will get q3 answer? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: R3 R4 expected. TheNewONe [-\]: + gogonuts [5d\]: not much choice for b imo - has to come in at k5 Muttley [2k\]: what's the winrate now? gogonuts [5d\]: even if his own moyo suffers fluidistic [5k\]: black will play N7 TheNewONe [-\]: no way Muttley [2k\]: is >60%? fluidistic [5k\]: or K5 fluidistic [5k\]: Muttley 66% rsun [5d\]: p3 first rs220675 [1d\]: maybe even a doulbe attack at m3 and then r3 to suck out all that is possible in this area Muttley [2k\]: thx, that's getting to be significant, from my humble stats perspective Ootakamoku [4d?\]: p3 is nice idea, to ask if b can easy invade corner or side Ootakamoku [4d?\]: but.. not sure why, I dont like it :( Duracell [?\]: n7 ? Muttley [2k\]: possible because it kills L3 aji, if you think there is aji there awesome [3k\]: inavde deep like a hero Ootakamoku [4d?\]: k5 seem fine to me rsun [5d\]: I guess p3 o3, then b got nothing,.. rsun [5d\]: k5, cs will k7 BreizhI [1k\]: How old has CS ? fluidistic [5k\]: born in 2005 I think fluidistic [5k\]: something like that wampleek [?\]: Born?? BreizhI [1k\]: hm 10 years rsun [5d\]: remi, does cs know b18 ko? Muttley [2k\]: is it a ko with a dog leg? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: I don't know, but I see B18 here and there in the PV. rsun [5d\]: what is PV? RobotZombi [1k\]: how many of us would have considered playing N5 with white here? fluidistic [5k\]: primary variation RemiCoulom [3k?\]: principal variation. fluidistic [5k\]: or principal rsun [5d\]: ic thx RobotZombi [1k\]: I'd never have thought of it gogonuts [5d\]: b18 doesnt work properly when f17 isnt protected Ootakamoku [4d?\]: pv is basically the tree part? cjr [3d\]: N5 is not strange move Ootakamoku [4d?\]: or the most probable branches in tree Leonidas [2k\]: n5 pro-ish Muttley [2k\]: it is easy to miss though, cjr fluidistic [5k\]: not necessarily ootakamoku I believe. it depends on the program gogonuts [5d\]: normally i think fj would just play k5 pretty quickly, but he can feel that he is beeing led by the nose Muttley [2k\]: I wouldn't have thought of something that tight ] ;B[mm]BL[914.939]C[rsun [5d\]: remi how was the politics in academia awesome [3k\]: no way rsun [5d\]: hey, n7 is my style cjr [3d\]: does CS give an expected lead? GoIngo [?\]: now cs will have home run dyago [5k\]: good call fluid fluidistic [5k\]: N7, 5k move... I might have played it fluidistic [5k\]: my first choice knowing it's too slow to win RemiCoulom [3k?\]: rsun: I don't know, was not involved in that. ] ;W[lm]WL[2164.506]C[gogonuts [5d\]: i think b is hoping that he can pull a fast one on cs, after cs defeends cjr [3d\]: yes, much easier for bot than human to pick a move in this kind of position pokale [2d?\]: i am pokale Leonidas [2k\]: well.. n7 certainly not bad, but isn't there anything better? Kretzsche [2k?\]: you think so lowly of fj it's incredible Ootakamoku [4d?\]: b better have a plan for the bottom RemiCoulom [3k?\]: I did my research alone with no funding. awesome [3k\]: fj must think of inavsion ] ;B[ll]BL[893.691]C[dyago [5k\]: b too far back now unless tricks appear rsun [5d\]: wow... Muttley [2k\]: actually, not sure b is that far behind Muttley [2k\]: seems more like around 5.5 pollux1: I thought b should hav fought rsun [5d\]: but doesn't the department give you some pressure if you don't get funding? backpack1 [3d\]: how about p3? Lumpenhund [5d\]: r18 not small ] ;W[nm]WL[2125.695]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: m6 Duracell [?\]: probe p3 now Ootakamoku [4d?\]: this looks like an opportunity for b gogonuts [5d\]: i would answer n8 pollux1: m6 or die RemiCoulom [3k?\]: rsun: no. jw24 [6k\]: winning percentage now? fluidistic [5k\]: 68% I guess... Ootakamoku [4d?\]: gogo, how does w continue against b m6? rsun [5d\]: that's good to know RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 67.8% jw24 [6k\]: wow cjr [3d\]: Remi, couldn't you make some heat maps and cool things like that for the game analysis? :) rsun [5d\]: I always thought it was impossible to do pure research nowadays ] ;B[ml]BL[827.732]C[AboutDan [2k\]: fluid, nice guess gogonuts [5d\]: prob with o dyago [5k\]: p8 fluidistic [5k\]: only way to win for black is by creating a magic ko rs220675 [1d\]: cs is cruising... Ootakamoku [4d?\]: m6 o8 n6 o6 p5 o5 n3 BreizhI [1k\]: Rémy you wasn't working for CNRS ? ] ;W[bb]WL[2086.901]C[awesome [3k\]: lol fluidistic [5k\]: B18 hahaha gogonuts [5d\]: b had to play n8 to keep the top and hes hoping defense is hard for cs now ] ;B[be]BL[817.958]C[Duracell [?\]: b looks still fine Ootakamoku [4d?\]: err.. last move in sequence at o3, not n3 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Breizhl: I was Maître de Conférences. Member of a CNRS lab, too. French system is complicated. gogonuts [5d\]: i dont agree with b18 Lumpenhund [5d\]: c17? BreizhI [1k\]: yeah , jsuis en plein de dans :) ] ;W[bf]WL[2048.609] ;B[de]BL[816.361]C[gogonuts [5d\]: it opens ws weakness at f17 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Back to 65% dyago [5k\]: bot luring well globax [3d\]: counteratari cjr [3d\]: E15 now? fluidistic [5k\]: bots usually mess up corners :( ] ;W[ee]WL[2009.905]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: this gives b one lib tho Ootakamoku [4d?\]: which removes ko, no? ] ;B[cf]BL[804.143]C[dyago [5k\]: white gets into side now Ootakamoku [4d?\]: actually, can even fill and still remove ko Ootakamoku [4d?\]: because of e14 and f17 aji ] ;W[df]WL[1970.753]C[gogonuts [5d\]: c18 now, imo Zenmid [6k\]: CS has optimistic feeling, so shoule have selected safety movement... ] ;B[cb]BL[792.463]C[gogonuts [5d\]: fj agrees :-) dyago [5k\]: how does a 6d fall for that? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: dyago, it was CS who fell for something, not b ] ;W[bc]WL[1932.143]C[dyago [5k\]: b12 fluidistic [5k\]: cs is 6d ] ;B[ba]BL[783.226]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: I know, but I assumed he was refering to b with the comment dyago [5k\]: i was fluidistic [5k\]: ah ok dyago [5k\]: b lives but w gains poits, terriroty and likely sente fluidistic [5k\]: bot mess up corner is rule of thumb. ] ;W[rn]WL[1893.349]C[GoIngo [?\]: losing the corner makes whole-board evaluation simpler for CS pokale [2d?\]: w is the strongest robot? gogonuts [5d\]: not good by w in the upper left dyago [5k\]: zen gogonuts [5d\]: bad for endgame rsun [5d\]: CS stronger Kretzsche [2k?\]: b is the strongest robot fluidistic [5k\]: strongest bot is unknown until they don't create a rating list ] ;B[rm]BL[747.507]C[fluidistic [5k\]: and test under equal hardware Zenmid [6k\]: CS is one of the strongest robot in the world rsun [5d\]: hideki is here in fact qpax [1d\]: zen is better than cs dyago [5k\]: they play each other every now and ten dyago [5k\]: i like zens style best fluidistic [5k\]: yeah but on different hardwares gogonuts [5d\]: cs is king of the hill until proven otherwise Ootakamoku [4d?\]: gogo, question in the clone, care to take a look? fluidistic [5k\]: these games are worthless to discuss which is the best dyago [5k\]: i never see zen play with long time like this game ] ;W[ql]WL[1854.123] ;B[ro]BL[735.453]C[dyago [5k\]: anotyer bot screw up? cjr [3d\]: R8? awesome [3k\]: r8 interesting ] ;W[rp]WL[1834.158]C[TheNewONe [-\]: first BreizhI [1k\]: a17 leads to a ko ? cjr [3d\]: looks like a misclick, maybe a wrong index somewhere in the code? :) TheNewONe [-\]: bots learn to play shapes moves ] ;B[sn]BL[721.761]C[TheNewONe [-\]: r8 isn't missclick that i say TheNewONe [-\]: it is shape move TheNewONe [-\]: i mean dyago [5k\]: i agree dyago [5k\]: looks great TheNewONe [-\]: if we remove r14 and n8 TheNewONe [-\]: it is normal move to attack b ;) jinroo [2d?\]: r8 looks terrible dyago [5k\]: p8 jinroo [2d?\]: the timing jinroo [2d?\]: at least ] ;W[nn]WL[1795.319]C[gogonuts [5d\]: cs is getting a little funky cjr [3d\]: and creates bad aji in lower right Ootakamoku [4d?\]: p8 natural Kretzsche [2k?\]: it's called crazy stone for a reason fluidistic [5k\]: successor of crazy bishop Ootakamoku [4d?\]: with the w shape so bad at the bottom, it looks easy to live there now cjr [3d\]: leading too much with the R18 endgame perhaps? backpack1 [3d\]: q8 is natural ] ;B[pl]BL[635.027]C[cjr [3d\]: making sure O6 is sente and then protect at K5 or K6 dyago [5k\]: k5 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: b r3 should givelife tho globax [3d\]: r18 sequence, then k6 ] ;W[nl]WL[1756.435] ;B[nk]BL[625.313]C[dyago [5k\]: pesky bot awesome [3k\]: r18 ends in sente for b? gogonuts [5d\]: surely r3 gets something for b now GoIngo [?\]: remi, % please ] ;W[ok]WL[1717.467]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: someone wants n6 in sente.. awesome [3k\]: tenuki? ] ;B[ol]BL[592.425]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: hmm, I wonder if b could have played m6 instead of p8 ] ;W[mk]WL[1697.025]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: h, cant, then r6 gies Ootakamoku [4d?\]: dies* ] ;B[nj]BL[578.266]C[dyago [5k\]: why does se show stones at s-t 16 17? ] ;W[km]WL[1669.936]C[Leonidas [2k\]: hey btw, is there commentary on game 1 yet? ] ;B[kl]BL[576.146]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: dyago, because its SE rsun [5d\]: I don't think there will be any commentary dyago [5k\]: is it assuming a sequence? gogonuts [5d\]: im not impressed by cs since b18 afar [3d?\]: dyago: No, it's just really inaccurate dyago [5k\]: thx ] ;W[bm]WL[1631.11]C[gogonuts [5d\]: somebody disabled a couple of cores? :-) dyago [5k\]: ha cjr [3d\]: fj maybe ] ;B[bn]BL[562.014]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: dyago, dont read too much into SE, its like a 15kyu, when it comes to guessing what is dead and alive, its good for couting tho, when its japanese rules, and you first help it understand which groups are alive and dead dyago [5k\]: or added some random junk dyago [5k\]: thx First [3k?\]: score estimate is great First [3k?\]: for counting awesome [3k\]: don't listen to that, se does extremely advanced analysis to provide you the correct estimate of the game fluidistic [5k\]: well from now and on looks like black can reduce whtie but not the other way around First [3k?\]: which is exactly what it does ] ;W[cm]WL[1591.943]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: gote Ootakamoku [4d?\]: invade bottom cjr [3d\]: w still has R18, which is pretty huge fluidistic [5k\]: SE is good in japanese rules fluidistic [5k\]: in chinese rules it's useless rsun [5d\]: do not speak evil of SE, or it will kill all your stones in your next game ] ;B[cn]BL[530.465]C[gogonuts [5d\]: yes, the secret6 fight is if w gets r18 or not dyago [5k\]: it would be intersting if each bot showed its se ] ;W[an]WL[1552.396]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: with that in mind, b should ask o19 asap ] ;B[ao]BL[525.354]C[Muttley [2k\]: Score est discusses rule sets with sum rsun [5d\]: lol wazi [3k\]: SE 10d? gogonuts [5d\]: if i read it correctly r18 gets w 1000y ko fluidistic [5k\]: A6??? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: how about just r18 and connect under? ] ;W[cr]WL[1512.819]C[gogonuts [5d\]: a6? backpack1 [3d\]: SE cant be that nuts... fluidistic [5k\]: what the.... ] ;B[br]BL[519.428]C[gogonuts [5d\]: b1 now? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: r18 q16 q19 r17 p19 q17 s18 yose for w dyago [5k\]: d8 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: bottom left sequence is weird, since w cant play a7 anwyays ] ;W[dr]WL[1473.313] ;B[bs]BL[511.979]C[fluidistic [5k\]: K7 gogonuts [5d\]: better r18 q16 r17 p15 s15 o19 m18 s18 s19 s17 t18 t17 t15 imo dyago [5k\]: j6 ] ;W[jm]WL[1434.969]C[awesome [3k\]: l5 ] ;B[im]BL[504.236]C[awesome [3k\]: you win fluid Kretzsche [2k?\]: letters and numbers cjr [3d\]: K7 ugly fluidistic [5k\]: now J6 :) fluidistic [5k\]: or H8 ] ;W[in]WL[1396.215]C[awesome [3k\]: you can't hedge your bets Muttley [2k\]: h6? fluidistic [5k\]: ok so I win again :D awesome [3k\]: now this one doesn't count RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 63%. Win rate steadily decreasing. GoIngo [?\]: thx for info GoRoGoRo [?\]: @Ingo: thx for reading ] ;B[hm]BL[450.739]C[gogonuts [5d\]: theremust be some inaccuracies in cs corner evaluations here rs220675 [1d\]: is r3 still a real threat for black? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: gogo, ya, looks better gogonuts [5d\]: y RemiCoulom [3k?\]: gogo: probably. ] ;W[hn]WL[1356.679]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: all the more reason b shoudl ask o19 awesome [3k\]: be a hero and invade fluidistic [5k\]: black t4 anytime Leonidas [2k\]: maybe the monte carlo effect is kicking in? bot can afford to let winrate drop.. just not below 50% ] ;B[dl]BL[432.891]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: as it removes both possible endgame sequences from the corner, in sente, assuming o19 gets m18 answer pokale [2d?\]: i count w+49.5 pokale [2d?\]: why doesn't b resign? ] ;W[dk]WL[1330.557]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: leonidas, bots dont drop winrate, they drop the score margin Kretzsche [2k?\]: maybe he has a different count from you RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 62% ] ;B[gm]BL[410.474]C[gogonuts [5d\]: happy g7 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: fun aji here ] ;W[el]WL[1311.08]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: this probably lets b invade the bottom awesome [3k\]: cool! ] ;B[ln]BL[400.4]C[GoRoGoRo [?\]: L5 fluidistic [5k\]: K6 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: I thought b would paly l5 right away GoRoGoRo [?\]: (to guess something) dyago [5k\]: sacrifice ] ;W[qb]WL[1272.683] ;B[pd]BL[393.818]C[gogonuts [5d\]: shorte cs: this all stinks Muttley [2k\]: gosh ] ;W[qc]WL[1252.956]C[Kretzsche [2k?\]: hu? ] ;B[oe]BL[382.007]C[wampleek [?\]: Bad timing nhanh [3d\]: o19 gogonuts [5d\]: will it find 1000y ko? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: ask o19 now Muttley [2k\]: I wondered whether b could connect like this gogonuts [5d\]: or degenerate to direct ko, like most bots? Muttley [2k\]: yeah, this is the ko BreizhI [1k\]: s15 nox ? ] ;W[oa]WL[1214.65]C[BreizhI [1k\]: now* ] ;B[pa]BL[376.255]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: hmm, uncodiotjnal life Ootakamoku [4d?\]: take that gogonuts [5d\]: not helpful Muttley [2k\]: no, it wants to set up living shape gogonuts [5d\]: b endgame pretty big plains [4d\]: it could alive :o dyago [5k\]: s15 ] ;W[qa]WL[1176.081]C[Muttley [2k\]: so it will manufacture R19 ir S19 somehow ] ;B[na]BL[371.146]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: ya, 1000y ko without sacrifcing yose on the other side would be better gogonuts [5d\]: not worth the price imo gogonuts [5d\]: b m18 is big Ootakamoku [4d?\]: b l17? rs220675 [1d\]: does black still have chances? this looks to me like black would resign in a normal match ] ;W[re]WL[1137.13]C[Muttley [2k\]: I think b has a chance Kretzsche [2k?\]: yea but you are 1d and b is 6d pokale [2d?\]: its gote so b also gets to invade bottom futher ] ;B[ld]BL[354.528]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: same idea as l17, except dont allow for w to attempt bad ko gogonuts [5d\]: cute ] ;W[lc]WL[1114.093] ;B[kc]BL[353.451]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: and costs b a few points gogonuts [5d\]: fj payback time miao [6d\]: maybe L17 was suji wampleek [?\]: Wow wampleek [?\]: Huge awesome [3k\]: cool moves here RemiCoulom [3k?\]: back to 59% ] ;W[le]WL[1094.616] ;B[lb]BL[352.161]C[gogonuts [5d\]: this looks good to me pokale [2d?\]: living with r15 really not worth it ] ;W[ld]WL[1074.836]C[GoRoGoRo [?\]: go fj, go! ] ;B[jc]BL[349.213]C[wolokom [5k\]: i love b Ootakamoku [4d?\]: l5 gogonuts [5d\]: the problem wa s that it paid this huge price for r19 lepore [1d\]: win rate? gogonuts [5d\]: i think it didnt see 1000y ko fluidistic [5k\]: look above lepore ] ;W[ma]WL[1035.755] ;B[la]BL[336.132]C[dyago [5k\]: j18 nhanh [3d\]: hmm GoRoGoRo [?\]: W panicking already? yutyu: cs made mistake awesome [3k\]: fun when bots panic :) ] ;W[id]WL[996.782]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: naa, game sily when bots panic Ootakamoku [4d?\]: back to bottom now ] ;B[gn]BL[321.329]C[fluidistic [5k\]: come on cs Ootakamoku [4d?\]: and CS not panicking yet poire [3d\]: Remi Coulon: Does the program choose the risk in inverse proportion to win rate? That is, if the winrate had been 87% say, would Black have chosen to just grab yose points at P19? ] ;W[ko]WL[975.237]C[Kretzsche [2k?\]: fun when kibitz read all kind of nonsense into moves they dont understand fluidistic [5k\]: L5 yessss gogonuts [5d\]: uh oh backpack1 [3d\]: why not L5 ] ;B[go]BL[309.322]C[gogonuts [5d\]: now fj got to fancy GoRoGoRo [?\]: @poire: B is notbot backpack1 [3d\]: b should ve yutyu: L5 si gigger than P19 ] ;W[fo]WL[955.754]C[gogonuts [5d\]: maybe i take that back# gogonuts [5d\]: backdoor also nice Ootakamoku [4d?\]: poire, almost all monte carlo bots, choose moves that remove L&D situations, even if it costs lots of points, when they have big margin of win, since less L&D means less variance in results, and hence higher winrate. fluidistic [5k\]: who's leading gogonuts? FoH [-\]: huuge ] ;B[kn]BL[290.083]C[gogonuts [5d\]: dunno rs220675 [1d\]: and black has still r3 right? ] ;W[jn]WL[936.436]C[fluidistic [5k\]: winrate 52%? Xebo [4d\]: cs still thinks its leading? ] ;B[mn]BL[283.09]C[jinroo [2d?\]: dont think thats working gogonuts [5d\]: b will prob ask at p5 instead of r3 now Ootakamoku [4d?\]: n6 is nice, makes r3 work well gogonuts [5d\]: but not sure RemiCoulom [3k?\]: 60% yutyu: p5-> r3 fluidistic [5k\]: 60% yes!!!!! ] ;W[lo]WL[897.725]C[dyago [5k\]: k4 nhanh [3d\]: g6 doesn't look like best move Ootakamoku [4d?\]: fluidistic, you running this position on some bot? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: zen? qpax [1d\]: if w can play r8 and still win, then I'm impressed ] ;B[jo]BL[264.815]C[fluidistic [5k\]: no ootaka ] ;W[io]WL[878.355]C[gogonuts [5d\]: very nice cut gogonuts [5d\]: sneaking in pokale [2d?\]: game over rsun [5d\]: fluid didn't buy any bot awesome [3k\]: j4? ] ;B[ip]BL[240.542]C[poire [3d\]: OOtakamoku: thanks, but it seems to me that white's sequence just now is INCREASING the L&D risk, since the corneris a ko (which must be well know to bots). However, it seems to me that white can win rather safely by choose to get the yose points. so I wonder if the 62% win rate is "foolong" it. RedOni [3d\]: ýe Kretzsche [2k?\]: can it be called sneaking in when you use brute moves like a crow bar? gogonuts [5d\]: lol ] ;W[jp]WL[858.816] ;B[ho]BL[236.136] ;W[jo]WL[839.369] ;B[hp]BL[228.592]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: fix r3 eric1010 [1d\]: j2 gogonuts [5d\]: j2 holds the line though ] ;W[sf]WL[819.653]C[gogonuts [5d\]: ah Ootakamoku [4d?\]: t14 lol Ootakamoku [4d?\]: gote for white awesome [3k\]: hmmm jinroo [2d?\]: huge ] ;B[sg]BL[217.707]C[gogonuts [5d\]: fj will hate that gogonuts [5d\]: stolen sente Ootakamoku [4d?\]: t14 is not big, since its gote jinroo [2d?\]: gote ? jinroo [2d?\]: so sente Ootakamoku [4d?\]: seki in corner ] ;W[se]WL[800.134]C[jinroo [2d?\]: nope Ootakamoku [4d?\]: if white tenukies gogonuts [5d\]: ah true gogonuts [5d\]: sente seki ] ;B[rg]BL[208.33]C[fluidistic [5k\]: it will tenuki Ootakamoku [4d?\]: yes globax [3d\]: j2 jinroo [2d?\]: how ? awesome [3k\]: is seki so big for b? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: which means most defiantely lose points from that exchange cjr [3d\]: there is also a ko variation BreizhI [1k\]: b ~ 81 w ~83 there is a komi ? cjr [3d\]: althought it is almost never possible globax [3d\]: j2 or j18.? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: that exchange, is 4 points, in sente, but sente seki in corner is worth 8 points GoIngo [?\]: komi 6.5 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: so, gain 4 in sente, then lose 8 in sente, does not add up gogonuts [5d\]: s17 t18 s18 t17 s19 t16 ] ;W[ab]WL[761.81]C[BreizhI [1k\]: w win cjr [3d\]: hmm Uniqo [1d\]: seki is 7 points gote gogonuts [5d\]: seki is sente dyago [5k\]: this is fun GoRoGoRo [?\]: B less than 4 minutes BreizhI [1k\]: Isn't A 17 better ? ] ;B[cc]BL[176.531]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: well, w can play ko for the whole corner, if refuse sente seki GoRoGoRo [?\]: will this become an issue? GoIngo [?\]: after that 40 seconds per mopve cjr [3d\]: but plenty of byoyomi gogonuts [5d\]: byoyomi is generous GoIngo [?\]: + 5 byo phases dyago [5k\]: d19 gogonuts [5d\]: should not be a problem Uniqo [1d\]: ah, preventing seki is reverse sente 7 points ] ;W[il]WL[723.086]C[fluidistic [5k\]: bug pokale [2d?\]: CrazyStone: Why did you program me to feel pain gogonuts [5d\]: cs breaking Ootakamoku [4d?\]: uniqo, hmm, ok, so in that case, seki should be counted as 7 points too RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Looks like nonsense move because it does not understand the corner. Ootakamoku [4d?\]: so ya, I was wrong, its 7 points in sente, not 8 :) wazi [3k\]: NullPointerException :)) ] ;B[hl]BL[138.44]C[dyago [5k\]: seems to be a pattern in moves like this dyago [5k\]: gotta be planed fluidistic [5k\]: hopefully cs fix the corner (and lose it) so it becomes normal again gogonuts [5d\]: lol RobotZombi [1k\]: white was hoping black would not see H8? Muttley [2k\]: I'm puzzled, but that's because I have a different algorithmic approach to specific positions I guess qpax [1d\]: seki in the top right is gote for b ] ;W[hk]WL[684.663]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: muttley, does your algorithm involve dices? Muttley [2k\]: no, bones leboss [6k?\]: who is winning ] ;B[ik]BL[126.056]C[dyago [5k\]: w lepore [1d\]: seems b ahead no? rs220675 [1d\]: b nhanh [3d\]: :) chicken bones? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: I prefere tea leaves gogonuts [5d\]: judging by these last moves cs is going down dyago [5k\]: puer Muttley [2k\]: :) oliolioli [2k\]: b ahead HTakagi: b will win gogonuts [5d\]: but dont bet your life on it ] ;W[ea]WL[646.021]C[shellgame [2d?\]: bones like dominoes, or cannibles? ] ;B[da]BL[106.025]C[Muttley [2k\]: cannibals, if you must :) Hendl [1d\]: difference lesser than komi i think Uniqo [1d\]: qpax, s17 is sente seki http://senseis.xmp.net/?RectangularEightInTheCorner rs220675 [1d\]: %? dyago [5k\]: j17 awesome [3k\]: r3 already! ] ;W[ib]WL[606.885]C[dyago [5k\]: cs wants an r3 battle gogonuts [5d\]: connecting at f19 is pretty heavy because b gets endgame from the other side jinroo [2d?\]: r3 not working anymore I think wolokom [5k\]: oh ] ;B[gb]BL[87.679]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: b can ask p5 first gogonuts [5d\]: simply g18 fluidistic [5k\]: hurts fluidistic [5k\]: big time dyago [5k\]: k18 jinroo [2d?\]: b gets o6 yes gogonuts [5d\]: e19 for d19 is terrible now ] ;W[gc]WL[568.514] ;B[fa]BL[82.522]C[wolokom [5k\]: b is ahead very easy now gogonuts [5d\]: yes, b can see the harbor lepore [1d\]: so two ways to get seki in top right, which one ends in sente for b? fluidistic [5k\]: w has weaknesses everywhere ] ;W[fc]WL[533.255]C[gogonuts [5d\]: tenuki Ootakamoku [4d?\]: the r3 invasion now looks very complicated WhiteRawr [5d\]: j2 gogonuts [5d\]: no need ] ;B[gr]BL[55.725]C[awesome [3k\]: nice wolokom [5k\]: hm gogonuts [5d\]: messing around here is great for b backpack1 [3d\]: g2 is cool gogonuts [5d\]: w didnt get to play j2 WhiteRawr [5d\]: good move ] ;W[fr]WL[513.975] ;B[hq]BL[50.885] ;W[fq]WL[494.27] ;B[jq]BL[49.667]C[gogonuts [5d\]: fj is like a slave freed of his chains now :-) Ootakamoku [4d?\]: k3 makes r3 work I think :P ] ;W[kq]WL[472.114]C[dyago [5k\]: and like most masters they're idiots ] ;B[kr]BL[47.07]C[Hendl [1d\]: fjango unchained backpack1 [3d\]: k2>k3? cjr [3d\]: but can't say it was a convincing win cjr [3d\]: if it is one Gigantom [3k\]: nice hendl :D rs220675 [1d\]: agreed, cjr wolokom [5k\]: j 2 oliolioli [2k\]: looks fairly convincing to me tantrika [4k\]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Frd53vbCHLg Hendl ! ] ;W[jr]WL[433.811] ;B[ir]BL[43.841]C[Mneme [2k\]: Rémi % ? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: less than 50% for sure gogonuts [5d\]: well he went down badly in the first, and this one seemed to follow the pattern, so a slightly dirty win is fine poire [3d\]: GOGOnuts: yes, but it is lucky win for him. it seems that white CHOSE the losing seuence, rather than black FINDING a winning one globax [3d\]: k1? ] ;W[iq]WL[394.995]C[oliolioli [2k\]: I only just tuned in so i missed that.. globax [3d\]: go under ! rs220675 [1d\]: done, fj wins Ootakamoku [4d?\]: p5 good threat gogonuts [5d\]: maybe r3? RemiCoulom [3k?\]: cs is losing now. wolokom [5k\]: ah ko krimmi dyago [5k\]: r3 now ] ;B[rc]BL[4.507]C[awesome [3k\]: why not just k1? rs220675 [1d\]: k1 and cs can resign Ootakamoku [4d?\]: dont like s17 as a threat gogonuts [5d\]: or just that gogonuts [5d\]: a 2nd ko or sente seki on the way Ootakamoku [4d?\]: unless he plays out the whole sequence fluidistic [5k\]: why ootaka? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: because ko and seki comparable in size ] ;W[rb]WL[356.591]C[fluidistic [5k\]: ok ] ;B[jq]BL[40]OB[5]C[gogonuts [5d\]: so that corner has a ko now too fluidistic [5k\]: thx Ootakamoku [4d?\]: and the topright ko is bigger than this ko Ootakamoku [4d?\]: not that it makes a difference, b has won gogonuts [5d\]: but next threat better r3 than t18, imo ] ;W[bq]WL[317.768]C[rs220675 [1d\]: why didn't fj just play k1? isn't he leading convincingly now? jinroo [2d?\]: play the ko is more severe and sharp way of play WhiteRawr [5d\]: because humiliating a bot is much more stisfying Leonidas [2k\]: fj knows we like to watch the bot struggle ] ;B[aq]BL[40]OB[5]C[jinroo [2d?\]: I think he likes to play like that rs220675 [1d\]: :) oliolioli [2k\]: life on the edge Ootakamoku [4d?\]: you get addicted to the trashing part Freund [3d?\]: he told us, to play a ko ;) Ootakamoku [4d?\]: and its really bad to like it, cause it hurts you own judgement in games vs humans WhiteRawr [5d\]: ;-) ] ;W[iq]WL[279.393]C[gogonuts [5d\]: i dont like it - i trash my opponents with a sad heart :-) ] ;B[js]BL[40]OB[5]C[rs220675 [1d\]: what's cs % analysis now? RobotZombi [1k\]: -100% Muttley [2k\]: below 50% rsun [5d\]: cs % doesn't matter now ] ;W[jq]WL[240.972]C[oliolioli [2k\]: can it resign it self? rsun [5d\]: yes Ootakamoku [4d?\]: ok, start topright ko now ] ;B[oo]BL[40]OB[5]C[rs220675 [1d\]: m2...and having a good time Freund [3d?\]: how big is M2? pokale [2d?\]: lol gogonuts [5d\]: m2 would make w defend the corner JIeBuc [5d?\]: not rly gogonuts [5d\]: so asking first at p5 is better JIeBuc [5d?\]: not rly big Ootakamoku [4d?\]: so, make w play p4 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: then start ko, and use r3 threats oliolioli [2k\]: looks big, why do you say not big? ] ;W[bp]WL[202.607]C[Hendl [1d\]: r2 coming? rs220675 [1d\]: black is too much ahead to worry about those things gogonuts [5d\]: what is this? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: this is.. gote? WhiteRawr [5d\]: ;-) gogonuts [5d\]: w resignation may be close JIeBuc [5d?\]: its gote pokale [2d?\]: pooooor bot ] ;B[op]BL[40]OB[5]C[Hellhuman [1d?\]: w + time Morghulis [1d\]: wow DerMeyer [1k\]: lol rs220675 [1d\]: now even I could jump in to bring this game home :) dyago [5k\]: b wont lose on time come on ] ;W[oq]WL[183.268]C[backpack1 [3d\]: over ] ;B[lr]BL[40]OB[5]C[henry1010 [1k\]: W a2 works? Uniqo [1d\]: what about a2? rs220675 [1d\]: cs will resign exactly 6pm^^ Hendl [1d\]: looks risky ] ;W[mq]WL[163.621]C[GoKlaus [1k?\]: than b5 gogonuts [5d\]: a2 b5 henry1010 [1k\]: c1 cjr [3d\]: Remi went into hiding in the chat after bot started doing worse? Bot authors emotional too... perhaps working on improvements for next game :) ] ;B[qq]BL[40]OB[5]C[henry1010 [1k\]: a2 b5 c1? awesome [3k\]: all those w points on the bottom... where did they all go? lespeutere [6k\]: a4 gogonuts [5d\]: its not a double snapback gogonuts [5d\]: b has extra lib ] ;W[pq]WL[144.164] ;B[rq]BL[40]OB[5]C[henry1010 [1k\]: oh i see henry1010 [1k\]: thanks awesome [3k\]: b4 trick move WhiteRawr [5d\]: b4 bad move globax [3d\]: bravo fj and thanks remi WhiteRawr [5d\]: xD ] ;W[ar]WL[105.798]C[gogonuts [5d\]: here it comes ] ;B[bo]BL[40]OB[5]C[GoKlaus [1k?\]: the place to resign :) Hellhuman [1d?\]: c1 Hellhuman [1d?\]: ah kk Gotag [1k\]: how strong is CS on a typical home computers? I5 and 8gb ram ] ;W[cs]WL[66.727]C[JIeBuc [5d?\]: who knows ] ;B[ap]BL[40]OB[5]C[Hellhuman [1d?\]: How Strong would cs be on an oneplus one? rsun [5d\]: @goingo, I sent you some message oliolioli [2k\]: is he availible for install? rs220675 [1d\]: about 1d i guess, gotag Ootakamoku [4d?\]: on 9x9 board, cs is 4dan or something on a note 2 ] ;W[hb]WL[27.801]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: on 19x19 its probably around 4kyu JIeBuc [5d?\]: btw, i5 isnt rly typical. I still have core 2 duo and thats more than enough ] ;B[sb]BL[40]OB[5]C[gogonuts [5d\]: the finishing ko ] ;W[qp]WL[40]OW[5] ;B[sp]BL[40]OB[5]C[awesome [3k\]: cs got rid of the threats in lower left just in time Gotag [1k\]: so not a 5d on home machine? pity RemiCoulom [3k?\]: The problem is the connection at H10/G11 RemiCoulom [3k?\]: The playouts don't evaluate it 100% correctly. ] ;W[qr]WL[40]OW[5] ;B[rr]BL[40]OB[5]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: ouch :( crestfalen [1k\]: b3 ? Ootakamoku [4d?\]: hard to win, when you think you have extra 15 points or something that you donthave. gogonuts [5d\]: to it keeps trying to cut there in its search? ] ;W[no]WL[40]OW[5] ;B[mr]BL[40]OB[5]C[FoH [-\]: b3 a7 a1 c8 nhanh [3d\]: kill RemiCoulom [3k?\]: No, it keeps making threats elsewhere to delay the problem to the playouts. Ootakamoku [4d?\]: Im guessing, it doesnt try to cut there is search, but actually manages to cut there in playouts DerMeyer [1k\]: overkill gogonuts [5d\]: oh no nhanh [3d\]: must m4 now gogonuts [5d\]: horizon poisoned ] ;W[pm]WL[40]OW[5] ;B[qm]BL[40]OB[5]C[awesome [3k\]: wait how did w get o5? Muttley [2k\]: b3, just b4 awesome [3k\]: long ago ] ;W[oj]WL[40]OW[5]C[gogonuts [5d\]: to me cs downfall started with b18 Ootakamoku [4d?\]: hmm, play super greedy and do o2 now Ootakamoku [4d?\]: trying to kill tail! gogonuts [5d\]: after that nothing went right ] ;B[pj]BL[40]OB[5]C[JIeBuc [5d?\]: o2 is wrong backpack1 [3d\]: m4 JIeBuc [5d?\]: only m4 alive backpack1 [3d\]: and over miao [6d\]: o2 is ko RobotZombi [1k\]: white R19 was also a disaster ] ;W[po]WL[40]OW[5] ;B[on]BL[40]OB[5]C[rs220675 [1d\]: yes, it set up the invasion for black DasWiesel [9k\]: lol SE wazi [3k\]: what did he say? gogonuts [5d\]: i have yet to see a bot play this common 1000y ko correctly ] ;W[nr]WL[40]OW[5]C[DasWiesel [9k\]: s+85 JIeBuc [5d?\]: c6 l5 dead awesome [3k\]: nooooo ] ;B[pr]BL[40]OB[5]C[DasWiesel [9k\]: b+85 fluidistic [5k\]: white reduced to ashes DasWiesel [9k\]: impressive performance by fj ] ;W[oi]WL[40]OW[5]C[Ootakamoku [4d?\]: p1 gives ko TheNewONe [-\]: m4 awesome [3k\]: would you have believed this in the midgame? dyago [5k\]: more like a failure for a bot rs220675 [1d\]: but still I think fj was lucky, he didn't win this one, but cs lost it ] ;B[lp]BL[40]OB[5]C[CrazyStone [-\]: GTP Engine for CrazyStone (white): Crazy Stone version http://remi.coulom.free.fr/CrazyStone/ Muttley [2k\]: hmmm, its like two different bots were playing rsun [5d\]: better safe than sorry! FishJump [9k\]: k2 group dead? wazi [3k\]: it's over RobotZombi [1k\]: now it's dead, yes dyago [5k\]: l1 rsun [5d\]: n13 anything? gogonuts [5d\]: m4 shows that fj is still hurting from the last game Ootakamoku [4d?\]: rsun, b could just trade wazi [3k\]: :)) fluidistic [5k\]: gg Ootakamoku [4d?\]: congratz on win BreizhI [1k\]: gg fj [6d\]: thx awesome [3k\]: gg rsun [5d\]: congratulations GoRoGoRo [?\]: BRAAAAVOOOO! gogonuts [5d\]: sehr gut GoIngo [?\]: congrats to fj! DasWiesel [9k\]: wo Mneme [2k\]: congrats fj DasWiesel [9k\]: wow GoKlaus [1k?\]: gw!! Amenophis [6k?\]: thx Mneme [2k\]: it was epic agony [5k\]: good job! keiler [?\]: Gratulation FJ! Zweistein [8k\]: gratz fj kendama [3k\]: gratz RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Thanks, congratulations. FQ [6k\]: Großartig, super zurückgekommen, spannend, Gratulation FJ JIeBuc [5d?\]: why gz? Zenmid [6k\]: Nice game gogonuts [5d\]: ab w b18 gings auffwärts Amenophis [6k?\]: well done fj Nilpferd [1k\]: congrats fj thx remi Leonidas [2k\]: someone hacked CS and changed it to GnuGo mid-game dxxd [1k\]: thanks, gg rs220675 [1d\]: @fj: glückwunsch fj [6d\]: well... I liked the start, but suddenly I lost confidence Leonidas [2k\]: well played fj! GoRoGoRo [?\]: @Ingo: Du bist da. Guck doch mal wegen rsun wazi [3k\]: Leonidas: laugh quite hard =)) rs220675 [1d\]: why did u choose cross fuseki? gogonuts [5d\]: i thought too that it would fun of you - letting you only get close fj [6d\]: just managed to keep the game on my side, I felt rsun [5d\]: cross fuseki prevents moyo gogonuts [5d\]: i dont think that makes it easier though rsun [5d\]: indeed fj [6d\]: nothing os easy these days DerMeyer [1k\]: boah! gogonuts [5d\]: cs played very nicely including o17 maneuver DerMeyer [1k\]: phylosophy gogonuts [5d\]: but after that it snapped DerMeyer [1k\]: i rsun [5d\]: what's easy is cheesy rs220675 [1d\]: now it's 1-1, be prepared for another sanrensei next week lepore [1d\]: fj it seems w misplayed top right and then your advantage became obvious. is that accurate? fj [6d\]: I dont know rsun [5d\]: I can't tell when the turning point happened gogonuts [5d\]: paying such a high price for r19 sente was very bad, ture fj [6d\]: my brain is just tofu now gogonuts [5d\]: lol GoRoGoRo [?\]: ^^ lepore [1d\]: lol gogonuts [5d\]: you survived rsun [5d\]: brain is actually like tofu, in fact fj [6d\]: ^^ rs220675 [1d\]: do you wish you would have gotten 2h thinking time instead of 1h? Leonidas [2k\]: rsun.. same taste? gogonuts [5d\]: and you did very well when it came to punishing its mistakes rsun [5d\]: I doubt GoRoGoRo [?\]: Like Shakespeare put it once: to fu or not to fu that's the question gogonuts [5d\]: looking forward to next week :-) rsun [5d\]: still no response from goingo :( fj [6d\]: yes fj [6d\]: thanks for watching GoIngo [?\]: @rsun: you can not explain certain things in samalltalk GoRoGoRo [?\]: @Ingo: warum sagst Du nix? GoRoGoRo [?\]: ah da issser ja fj [6d\]: and thanks to codecentric of course GoKlaus [1k?\]: have a great game next Saturday GoIngo [?\]: thx to fj and to remi for participating! gogonuts [5d\]: yes, thanks to both RemiCoulom [3k?\]: Thanks everybody. blackh [10k\]: Great work, both of you! rsun [5d\]: you can leave me a message on senseis HTakagi: Thanks for a good game. GoIngo [?\]: @rsun: forget it. It seems we are too different. fj [6d\]: c u GoIngo [?\]: cu ])